The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Trek Tech (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=14)
-   -   Was the Ambassador Class phased out? (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=195178)

t_smitts November 26 2012 07:07 AM

Was the Ambassador Class phased out?
 
Having watched the Dominion War battle scene again recently, I was sorry we never saw a single Ambassador retaking DS9 or fighting at Chin'Toka. You'd think they'd be at least as common as the numerous Galaxies we saw.

I realize it comes down to which ships got a CG version and which didn't (Between the Defiant, Excelsior, Miranda, Galaxy, and inexplicably rare Nebula, plus the CG ships designed for "First Contact", I guess they thought they had enough), and I could see the Constellations being considered old and possibly phased out, and the small, fragile Oberths being considered unsuitable for combat, but the Ambassador would've been nice to see as well.

The last on-screen appearance of the ship was the Wolf 359 scenes in "Emissary", but the last chronological appearance was in TNG's 5th season. It's possible the class was phased out, or that not that many were ever made in the first place, but still...

Dukhat November 26 2012 07:24 AM

Re: Was the Ambassador Class phased out?
 
As I stated in another thread, the prevailing fandom explanation is that the Ambassador class was built primarily for deep-space exploration, and the reason why we never saw any was because they were all very far away. Of course, there's not a shred of canonical evidence to validate this theory.

King Daniel Into Darkness November 26 2012 10:24 AM

Re: Was the Ambassador Class phased out?
 
^I can see that being the reason why more specific mission-ships weren't seen during the Dominion war (kinda like how the USS Titan wasn't recalled during the Borg invasion in the novels), but the Ambassador class was supposed to be the Starfleet's mightiest and was just one generation behind the Galaxy class.

Maybe the Ambassadors were all just assigned to offscreen fleets - probably along with all the Niagra, Chyenne, Intrepid and Sovereign class ships.

Timo November 26 2012 12:40 PM

Re: Was the Ambassador Class phased out?
 
...Why do people say "Niagra"? The third "a" isn't missing from the pennants or the reference book entries, now is it?

There are real-world examples of certain ship types being exclusively used in certain theaters of war, so I have no major problem with that. What I find a bit odd is that the fleets operating near DS9 featured such a broad range of ships... The ones from the Galaxy generation ought to have been faster than the older ones, and must have felt incredibly frustrated and misused when forced to crawl at a fleet speed dictated by those Miranda relics and the oddball low-performance Defiants. Pairing capital ships from the in-between generations with the Miranda stock (that is, Ambassadors!) would have made better strategic sense.

Timo Saloniemi

Albertese November 26 2012 04:06 PM

Re: Was the Ambassador Class phased out?
 
Quote:

Timo wrote: (Post 7304821)
...Why do people say "Niagra"? The third "a" isn't missing from the pennants or the reference book entries, now is it?

...

Timo Saloniemi

No, but most people round off that middle "a" when they pronounce the word, so its easy enough to forget it's actually spelled Niagara.

I didn't even notice it was wrong til you pointed it out...

--Alex

T'Girl November 26 2012 05:35 PM

Re: Was the Ambassador Class phased out?
 
Maybe they just never built very many to start with. Therefor you don't see them for the same reason you don't see the newly created Sovereign Class, at the time of the Dominion War there are only two or three of them.

Pavonis November 26 2012 07:32 PM

Re: Was the Ambassador Class phased out?
 
How many Ambasadors were ever seen? The Zhukov and the Excaliber come to mind, and the Horatio was supposedly Ambassador-class, too. Any others? Excluding, of course, the Enterprise-C, as it was definitely destroyed long before the Dominion War.

C.E. Evans November 26 2012 09:15 PM

Re: Was the Ambassador Class phased out?
 
I think space is big. In some parts of the Galaxy, Ambassador-class ships may still be a fairly frequently seen design while you may see not see a single one in other areas.

Dukhat November 26 2012 09:21 PM

Re: Was the Ambassador Class phased out?
 
Other than the Nebula, we haven't seen any other BoBW kitbashes or DS9 kitbashes other than the few episodes they were in.

Plus, there's twenty-odd conjectural classes that we haven't seen even once.

Were they all phased out too?

(And yet we see tons of older designs such as the Excelsior, Miranda, and Oberth classes. Why weren't they phased out?)

Timo November 26 2012 09:27 PM

Re: Was the Ambassador Class phased out?
 
Quote:

Any others?
Apart from those mentioned, only the more or less unnamed one from DS9 "Emissary", identified by backstage means as having been labeled the Yamaguchi, was seen on screen.

In TNG "Second Chances", the show-and-tell Okudagram describing the duplication of Will Riker featured an Ambassador class silhouette to describe USS Potemkin, Will's old ship, but backstage sources have traditionally identified that ship as an Excelsior, as per the one and only onscreen appearance of a ship of that name in TNG, in "Ethics".

That is, we saw the Excelsior class vessel that had apparently ferried Dr. Russell to the hero ship for the adventure of the week, and Russell said she had some gear aboard the Potemkin, suggesting this was the name of the ferry vessel - but of course the ship we saw had no name or registry visible, and in theory Russell might have been expecting some of her equipment to arrive on a later ship. Or something.

Certainly it would also be possible that there were two ships of that name in the 2360s, and the Ambassador class one was lost at some point and replaced by an Excelsior. Both classes might have remained in production, and canonically we never quite saw the registry of either vessel so we can't derive chronological ques from that, either. (There are some blurry onscreen Okudagrams with various registry options, though.)

Timo Saloniemi

T'Girl November 26 2012 09:32 PM

Re: Was the Ambassador Class phased out?
 
Large number of B-52's flying around multiple decades after their construction. Other younger bombers have come and gone in the same time period.

All starships might not be created equal.

MacLeod November 26 2012 09:49 PM

Re: Was the Ambassador Class phased out?
 
It might be that some of those older Miranda etc... ships, were older ships that werer in mothballs (fleet reserves etc..) and reactivated to boolster the fleet.

t_smitts November 27 2012 12:31 AM

Re: Was the Ambassador Class phased out?
 
Quote:

MacLeod wrote: (Post 7307044)
It might be that some of those older Miranda etc... ships, were older ships that werer in mothballs (fleet reserves etc..) and reactivated to boolster the fleet.

Someone else on Youtube suggested the same thing, but I'm skeptical of that, simply because of the sheer number of Mirandas we saw.

I tend to see the Miranda, like the Excelsior, as a multipurpose design that was used for such varied uses as surveying already-charted planets for things like colonization or mining (Reliant), science vessels (Brattain) or a supply ship (Lantree). Most of them would've been pulled away from these duties and sent to join fleets at the start of the war.

Quote:

T'Girl wrote: (Post 7305727)
Maybe they just never built very many to start with. Therefor you don't see them for the same reason you don't see the newly created Sovereign Class, at the time of the Dominion War there are only two or three of them.

The absence of Sovereigns never bothered me, in the real-world sense that they might not want to show hero ships from other shows/movies. (We also never saw another Intrepid other than the Bellerophon)

I'm curious what exactly the cost (both in money and time) of creating a CG version of existing ship designs was.

MacLeod November 27 2012 01:19 AM

Re: Was the Ambassador Class phased out?
 
Well I said some, but given the sheer size of the Federation. It would seem likely that newer designs operated on the frontier, whilst older designs were relegated to milk runs so too speak.

t_smitts November 27 2012 02:44 AM

Re: Was the Ambassador Class phased out?
 
Quote:

MacLeod wrote: (Post 7308457)
Well I said some, but given the sheer size of the Federation. It would seem likely that newer designs operated on the frontier, whilst older designs were relegated to milk runs so too speak.

True, although I would imagine exploration took a rather low priority in the midst of war, especially war with such a formidable enemy. Hence the numerous Galaxy class (an obvious choice for deep space explorers) being assigned to fleets.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 12:07 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.