The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   The Next Generation (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=39)
-   -   Should they have kept Dr. Selar? (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=194497)

newtontomato539 November 19 2012 06:07 PM

Should they have kept Dr. Selar?
 
I thought she was a great character.

Mojochi November 19 2012 10:08 PM

Re: Should they have kept Dr. Selar?
 
Truthfully, I think it could have been useful to develop Crusher's staff more. I mean all we ever saw were Ogawa & Martinez. Seeing to the medical needs of a population of 1000 would require a developed staff, & the existence of Selar's character in season 2 suggested such a staff. If not to keep her around, then they should have at least added another medical staffer or two, with speaking parts

Hell, they could have scrapped 2 or 3 of those awful Crusher episodes like Sub Rosa, & put in something medical staff oriented, which would have still featured her heavily. I would have found a few more Starfleet medical stories fascinating

Geordi & Data had numerous episodes centered around technobabbly problems. A few centered around medical sci-fi would have been very refreshing

T'Girl November 20 2012 10:23 AM

Re: Should they have kept Dr. Selar?
 
Medical-babble?

Tosk November 20 2012 11:27 AM

Re: Should they have kept Dr. Selar?
 
Quote:

Mojochi wrote: (Post 7278358)
Truthfully, I think it could have been useful to develop Crusher's staff more. I mean all we ever saw were Ogawa & Martinez.

Yeah, but that's TNG all over really. How many characters beyond the main cast were explored in any real depth? A handful at best.

Not that I disagree with you though. It would have been nice to get more material for the supporting characters. :)

Mojochi November 20 2012 03:37 PM

Re: Should they have kept Dr. Selar?
 
Well, Ro was a bridge officer that was developed, & Barclay was something of an engineering officer they explored. I wouldn't say Guinan was extensively explored, but she was developed more than Ogawa. Ogawa shared the screen in Lower Decks & got an odd scene on occasion

Anyway... I just think even in this finite selection of supporting players, they could have squeezed in some more time for a sickbay one. Sickbay has always been a pretty integral part of all Star Trek

Tosk November 20 2012 03:41 PM

Re: Should they have kept Dr. Selar?
 
I wasn't actually arguing, I was agreeing. And lamenting that things were the way they were. Thankfully, when in need of a much larger expanded (and explored) cast there is another Trek show to go to. :)

Minuet November 20 2012 08:30 PM

Re: Should they have kept Dr. Selar?
 
There's several minor characters I wish they kept around. Ensign Gomez was another great character with a lot of potential for growth. I mean, she was a little obnoxious, but the idea of having a brilliant, attractive, yet naive and semi-neurotic female character evolving into something more and proving herself was a great idea. They eventually fulfilled that with Barclay, but Gomez would have been wonderful, and a possible love interest for Geordi.

Selar was nice, if they even remotely fleshed out her character. Even Gomez had more characterization than Selar.

Bry_Sinclair November 20 2012 10:26 PM

Re: Should they have kept Dr. Selar?
 
Selar should have been CMO from Season 2. She would have provided Data with a good counterpoint, whilst everyone else was trying to get him to be more human, she could signify the benefits of detachment and logic over wishy-washy emotions.

I also think that she and Worf would have made a interesting couple over the years, professionally and otherwise.

But then again, I am a little bias, I love Vulcans :vulcan:

C.E. Evans November 20 2012 10:35 PM

Re: Should they have kept Dr. Selar?
 
IMO, she would have been eventually TNG's version of Seven of Nine (an emotionless sex object). They probably would have made her uniform even tighter to show off her boobs--she definitely wouldn't be wearing a doctor's coat like Crusher did.

Mojochi November 21 2012 03:16 AM

Re: Should they have kept Dr. Selar?
 
Quote:

Tosk wrote: (Post 7281505)
I wasn't actually arguing, I was agreeing. And lamenting that things were the way they were. Thankfully, when in need of a much larger expanded (and explored) cast there is another Trek show to go to. :)

I wasn't really arguing either, just expounding, & I agree that if you want character exploring Star Trek then DS9 is the way to go, obviously, but I was always more a TNG guy, because the voyages of the Enterprise is where it's at for me, & they were the first to start exploring characters at all, compared to TOS. They could have stretched it a bit more, imho, but seemed tentative about doing so

I actually preferred Robin Lefler, who was featured slightly more than Gomez, & infinitely less obnoxious & green acting

Surak of Vulcan November 21 2012 04:39 AM

Re: Should they have kept Dr. Selar?
 
No doubt she should have appeared more often. If we didn't have inferring skills, then the entire medical staff of the USS Enterprise-D consisted of Crusher, Ogawa, and two Ensign Insignificants. However, there's a difference between the good guest stars, like Guinan or Barclay, and the bad guest stars, like a few of those ones that showed up just to spout out meaningless dross then hold the sets down for the rest of the episode.

And, as C.E. Evans stated, since I don't deny her rather attractive figure, she probably would've ended up as a Seven of Nine-esque character.

Also, if it helps, I believe she was in The New Frontier book series. But, books aren't canon, I know.

Forbin November 21 2012 03:56 PM

Re: Should they have kept Dr. Selar?
 
I'd like more Suzi Plakson in any guise.

Worf'sParmach November 25 2012 10:45 PM

Re: Should they have kept Dr. Selar?
 
Quote:

Forbin wrote: (Post 7285924)
I'd like more Suzi Plakson in any guise.

This.

Worf'sParmach November 25 2012 10:47 PM

Re: Should they have kept Dr. Selar?
 
Quote:

Bry_Sinclair wrote: (Post 7283236)
I also think that she and Worf would have made a interesting couple over the years, professionally and otherwise.

I've always thought seeing Worf with a Vulcan would have been interesting. He often behaves more logical Vulcan than impulsive Klingon anyway. And we already know Vulcans aren't opposed to going outside of their species.

Surak of Vulcan November 26 2012 02:38 AM

Re: Should they have kept Dr. Selar?
 
Quote:

Worf'sParmach wrote: (Post 7302637)
Quote:

Bry_Sinclair wrote: (Post 7283236)
I also think that she and Worf would have made a interesting couple over the years, professionally and otherwise.

I've always thought seeing Worf with a Vulcan would have been interesting. He often behaves more logical Vulcan than impulsive Klingon anyway. And we already know Vulcans aren't opposed to going outside of their species.

Well, Worf was more honorable than the average Klingon, too. According to Memory Alpha, if she was kept on, she was to have developed a relationship with Worf. Interesting, I must say. I wonder if they would've killed her off like they did with K'Ehleyr.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 01:27 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.