The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Star Trek Movies XI+ (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=50)
-   -   more nit picky questions (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=193618)

Pawleygirl November 10 2012 06:18 AM

more nit picky questions
 
I was curious about a few things... Do we know if Nero ever retrieved the board of protection codes for Earth's defense? If so, why were they never used, or was it pointless to even have them in the first place? Also, would the black hole red matter thing even work after the supernova has taken place?

Geoff Peterson November 10 2012 06:50 AM

Re: more nit picky questions
 
Quote:

Pawleygirl wrote: (Post 7234651)
I was curious about a few things... Do we know if Nero ever retrieved the board of protection codes for Earth's defense? If so, why were they never used, or was it pointless to even have them in the first place? Also, would the black hole red matter thing even work after the supernova has taken place?

Since he attacks Earth, I'm thinking yes.

Work in what way? Absorbing the supernova? We know Spock created a red matter black hole even after Romulas was destroyed, so the assumption is he created it to stop the supernova from causing more destruction.

F. King Daniel November 10 2012 11:31 AM

Re: more nit picky questions
 
Earth was being attacked, no one had a clue what was going on, so yeah - Nero got the codes. Not that Earth has ever been shown to have much in the way of defences, although they were spoken of in TMP.

"Frequencies please, sir." is one of my favourite lines from the movie. He's gonna keeeeel poor Christopher if he has to.


As for the supernova/black hole thing, it did work in the movie. Not so sure it'd work as a real-life solution to such a problem, though... not so sure such a problem is likely to come up, though. IRL a distant supernova would kill us with radiation, not a wall of fire.

Timo November 11 2012 09:48 PM

Re: more nit picky questions
 
Misusing super-secret codes would be a great way to neutralize an automated, integrated system of powerful defensive fortresses, which is what the ST:TMP dialogue seems to describe, and what we see in action in DS9 (albeit on Cardassian rather than UFP worlds).

But there should also be all sorts of "rogue" defense elements that would not be dependent on commands from an integrated system. Nero could shut down the big phaser fortress at the Moon and the defense satellites at 1,000 km orbits, but how would he stop the armed shuttles from launching from Edwards SFB?

Of course, he'd probably have all sorts of options available with the codes, beyond shutting down the defenses. He could tell defenses to fire on each other, he could order the fighter-shuttles to be launched towards Siberia rather than San Francisco, he could cut off power to anything from defensive cannon to the charging racks of phaser rifles in the nearest garrison. But that would call for some finesse, which a miner might lack.

Of course, a 24th century Romulan miner might have a "Disabling Primitive Planetary Defenses" computer application installed in his mainframe as standard; indeed, his government might insist that he carry one. Or Nero might have spent those 25 years cobbling together everything he needed to defeat UFP planets, and obtaining the necessary offensive program would be within his means even if none of his crew were expert programmers. Kidnapping was his major forte, after all...

But yeah, it seems clear that Nero got the codes to paralyze Earth from Pike. And also that he got the codes to paralyze Vulcan from somebody else, considering Vulcan never launched any fighter-shuttles, either.

(I mean, if Vulcan or Earth launched such things, we know of no possible defensive weapon that Nero could have used to stop them. Indeed, we see that he has no weapon he could use to stop Spock when the Vulcan uses a small craft to destroy the drill. Code trickery would appear to be Nero's only chance of pulling off these attacks.)

Timo Saloniemi


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 05:55 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.