The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Science Fiction & Fantasy (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=15)
-   -   Comic Book Events/Crossovers to read/avoid (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=161119)

JD February 10 2012 04:08 AM

Comic Book Events/Crossovers to read/avoid
 
As all of the people who post in comic book threads know pretty well by now, I'm just getting into comics and I keep hearing about this event and that event as I look at all of the different series I'm planning on reading. So this got me wondering, which ones are must reads, which ones are OK, and which I should avoid at all costs.
I remember reading on IGN a while back that DC's Amazon's Attack was horrible, and so far most of what I've heard about Marvel's Civil War and Secret Invasion don't seem to have gotten to bad of reactions.

OdoWanKenobi February 10 2012 04:13 AM

Re: Comic Book Events/Crossovers to read/avoid
 
Blackest Night was really good, but there's a ton of prerequisite reading for that one. It's like the culmination of seven years worth of Green Lantern stories.

Admiral_Young February 10 2012 04:25 AM

Re: Comic Book Events/Crossovers to read/avoid
 
Blackest Night the event book alone is pretty good, as OdoWan stated there is some reading to be done before it but that's because it is considered the third part in a trilogy. It also suffers from a TON of tie-in issues.

I'd avoid Marvel's Fear Its Self from last year...really disappointing, and they essentially undid everything that happened in the thing with their added on "Point" issues.

Mr Light February 10 2012 04:36 AM

Re: Comic Book Events/Crossovers to read/avoid
 
I thought "Flashpoint" was pretty horrible, as it was just one big what-if story with a reboot at the end.

Admiral_Young February 10 2012 04:38 AM

Re: Comic Book Events/Crossovers to read/avoid
 
Yeah I wasn't too impressed with "Flashpoint". Brian Azzerello's Batman tie-in though was great, probably the best of the bunch, including the event it's self.

JD February 10 2012 05:45 AM

Re: Comic Book Events/Crossovers to read/avoid
 
Quote:

OdoWanKenobi wrote: (Post 5789374)
Blackest Night was really good, but there's a ton of prerequisite reading for that one. It's like the culmination of seven years worth of Green Lantern stories.

Ohh, don't worry I plan on reading all of the stuff leading up to the events. I'm getting ready to start the lead up to Civil War, based of the list that was posted in one of the other threads, as soon I get money for comics. And I do plan on reading pretty much all, or at least as close to all of the Geoff Johns GL series as I can.

Myasishchev February 10 2012 05:58 AM

Re: Comic Book Events/Crossovers to read/avoid
 
I thought Blackest Night was pretty terrible (it was really, really repetitive), but if you like Johns' GL you might like it. But then, I liked Johns' Green Lantern a lot during and immediately after the Sinestro Corps War, too. That was pretty cool.

I've avoided buying every event at DC since Infinite Crisis (an OK mess, substantially better than Crisis on Infinite Earths, which is probably the worst comic no one has anything bad to say about that I've ever read, but IC suffers badly from Johns' inability to write humans qua humans, as opposed to plot devices in costumes; the Day of Judgment and Villains United tie-ins are, however, both extremely awesome, and really justify IC's existence all on their own; and I did read Final Crisis, but am very glad I didn't pay for it).

I'm not sure I've even read more than a dozen Marvel comics at all since Civil War. Although I actually liked Civil War itself quite a bit, I've rather disliked pretty much everything since then, and the one thing I thought could have been cool in the long run, Spider-Man's unmasking, obviously went away... from a distance, Secret Invasion, Siege, and Fear Itself (did I miss one?) have just seemed awful in every way.

If you go back a ways, Jim Starlin's Infinity Gauntlet/Infinity War/Infinity Crusade is well worth reading, particularly if you like space opera--and anything with Starlin and Adam Warlock beats Johns and Green Lantern with a stick, I'm just sayin'.* Indeed, I'm literally alone in thinking this, I'm sure, but Infinity War is the best comic Marvel ever published. Ron Lim is also possibly the most underrated artist I can think of. A spare descriptive style and clear storyteller, obviously a fast penciller, excellent with crowd scenes, and with a lot of Perezism in his panel compositions without approaching the Unreadable Nonsense Zone.

I also liked X-Tinction Agenda. Remember that, and I owe you a coke.

Valiant's Unity crossover was also really, really, really good. Indeed, everyone should go back and read the first two or three years of Valiant--all of it, every series, no kidding. It's good for you.

*In fact, while it's non-event related, but if you ever get a chance to read the 70s Warlock stuff Starlin did, take it. If nothing else, it's formally innovative stuff, but more importantly it's damn fun and it's some of the headiest mainstream comics ever got--I'd say it's at least as weird as Grant Morrison's median,and far more earnest in its weirdness.

Broccoli February 10 2012 06:04 AM

Re: Comic Book Events/Crossovers to read/avoid
 
Death of Superman trilogy

Admiral_Young February 10 2012 06:12 AM

Re: Comic Book Events/Crossovers to read/avoid
 
Batman: Knightfall Trilogy. DC is reprinting it just in time for the release of "The Dark Knight Rises". It has also been reprinting "No Man's Land" as well.

Myasishchev February 10 2012 06:27 AM

Re: Comic Book Events/Crossovers to read/avoid
 
Quote:

Broccoli wrote: (Post 5790067)
Death of Superman trilogy

That too! Art chores shared by multiple people led to really strong individual chapters and weak ones, though. I spent an hour looking for my trade of The Death of Superman the other day and never did find it (although I did find Death of Captain Marvel, close enough?).

Admiral_Young February 10 2012 06:48 AM

Re: Comic Book Events/Crossovers to read/avoid
 
I still want to get the Death and Return of Superman Omnibus eventually.

Broccoli February 10 2012 07:37 AM

Re: Comic Book Events/Crossovers to read/avoid
 
Quote:

Admiral_Young wrote: (Post 5790322)
I still want to get the Death and Return of Superman Omnibus eventually.

That seems like a good idea until you realize they left out chunks of the "World Without a Superman" arc.

Admiral_Young February 10 2012 02:17 PM

Re: Comic Book Events/Crossovers to read/avoid
 
Yeah I have read that criticism of it, maybe they'll correct that in the updated printing if there is one.

Icemizer February 10 2012 02:33 PM

Re: Comic Book Events/Crossovers to read/avoid
 
Well depending on how far back you want to go
Marvel Secret Wars-worth reading
Marvel Secret Wars II - Not worth reading
Marvel Contest of Champions- Good Story/Bad Math
Camalot 3000- worth reading as the first ever 12 issue Maxi-series
Squadron Supreme-the original 12 issue series is worth reading

Ok all those and a few more are from back before they were called Event comics. Books like The Dark Knight Returns and Green Arrow the Long Bow Hunters are not events per se but need to be read.

Forbin February 10 2012 02:40 PM

Re: Comic Book Events/Crossovers to read/avoid
 
Gotta say, after 40 years of collecting comics, I sick to death of events and crossovers. At this stage of life I'm only buying the few titles I've enjoyed all my life like Spidey and the Avengers - and only the main titles of each (I got REAL sick of buying 7 Spidey titles, 7 X-Men titles, yadda yadda, and trying to keep straight what's happening in each). I've never liked crossovers with books I don't get for obvious reasons. And Marvel's recent trend of big event series with their titles above the individual comic title is coming very close to turning me off comics for good.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 04:53 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.