The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Star Trek - Original Series (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=38)
-   -   The SINGLE GREATEST MOMENT in TOS !!! (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=157492)

Captain Tracy January 16 2012 12:59 PM

The SINGLE GREATEST MOMENT in TOS !!!
 
Considering all the great moments in The Original Series - be it: humor, action, suspense, intrigue, drama, or what-have-you - which scene, or single 'snap-shot', do you personally consider as:

'The Single Greatest Moment in TOS',... and more importantly, why ?

I'll start the ball rolling with my own personal 'winner'; though I must admit, it is only by an extremely thin margin that my personal vote does not go to KIRK's narrow escape of the booby-trapped Starship via a malfunctioning transporter in Norman Spinrad's, 'Doomsday Machine'.

My personal 'winner' is contained in 'ARENA', by Fredric Brown/ Gene L. Coon, wherein KIRK defeats the GORN, via the make-shift cannon on Cestus III.

Although both the 'Doomsday' and 'Arena' escape scenes have a high level of tension and consequence of failure - as both scenes rely on same dramatic device, that of playing 'beat-the-clock' - yet I feel the Brown/Coon scene wins by a nose for its use of having the added dimension of requiring KIRK to construct his own method of victory/escape, through sheer ingenuity and resourcefulness, ala' McGyver - while being chased no less! - rather than solely relying on the tension of being beamed-up in the nick-of-time; as effective as that is on its own.

Again, while it is an incredibly close-call for me, I personally must give my award to: KIRK defeats the GORN, via the make-shift cannon on Cestus III, as the SINGLE GREATEST MOMENT IN ALL OF TOS.

What scene or 'snap-shot' do you give your award to, and why?

foxhot January 16 2012 01:36 PM

Re: The SINGLE GREATEST MOMENT in TOS !!!
 
Before I read your actual posting, the conclusion of DOOMSDAY MACHINE automatically shot to my head. But I'm going to have to think long and hard on this one. For now, if we include the first six movies, I have to consider the destruction of the ENTERPRISE in THE SEARCH FOR SPOCK. It's the ultimate undoable moment in Classic Trek, whether they get a replacement lookalike ship or not.

Leaving out the films, the next moment that comes to mind is the death of Alexis Carringt------I'm sorry, Edith Keeler.

CorporalCaptain January 16 2012 01:55 PM

Re: The SINGLE GREATEST MOMENT in TOS !!!
 
Edith's death - because it's the most dramatic.

Captain Tracy January 16 2012 02:24 PM

Re: The SINGLE GREATEST MOMENT in TOS !!!
 
sorry,.. typo malfunction

Captain Tracy January 16 2012 02:32 PM

Re: The SINGLE GREATEST MOMENT in TOS !!!
 
[QUOTE=Captain Tracy;5609833]
Quote:

foxhot wrote: (Post 5609698)
...Leaving out the films, the next moment that comes to mind is the death of Alexis Carringt------I'm sorry, Edith Keeler.

Right FOXHOT, only looking at the 78 original series episodes, but you left out the most important part of your answer being the 'why' you award the scene or 'snap-shot' you have choosen. Please illuminate us!.

Captain Tracy January 16 2012 02:38 PM

Re: The SINGLE GREATEST MOMENT in TOS !!!
 
Quote:

CorporalCaptain wrote: (Post 5609734)
Edith's death - because it's the most dramatic.

Any specific reason why you find it as the most dramatic?

CorporalCaptain January 16 2012 02:52 PM

Re: The SINGLE GREATEST MOMENT in TOS !!!
 
Quote:

Captain Tracy wrote: (Post 5609893)
Quote:

CorporalCaptain wrote: (Post 5609734)
Edith's death - because it's the most dramatic.

Any specific reason why you find it as the most dramatic?

Kirk understands that there are casualties. Risk is their business. But this is one of the few times when he has to deliberately sacrifice someone for a greater good, and it was someone he loved. It's not an easy choice, it hurts Kirk a great deal, and the episode's delivery is extremely effective.

Captain Tracy January 16 2012 03:03 PM

Re: The SINGLE GREATEST MOMENT in TOS !!!
 
Quote:

CorporalCaptain wrote: (Post 5609956)
Quote:

Captain Tracy wrote: (Post 5609893)
Quote:

CorporalCaptain wrote: (Post 5609734)
Edith's death - because it's the most dramatic.

Any specific reason why you find it as the most dramatic?

Kirk understands that there are casualties. Risk is their business. But this is one of the few times when he has to deliberately sacrifice someone for a greater good, and it was someone he loved. It's not an easy choice, it hurts Kirk a great deal, and the episode's delivery is extremely effective.

Nice answer! :techman:

SchwEnt January 16 2012 04:42 PM

Re: The SINGLE GREATEST MOMENT in TOS !!!
 
Maybe obvious, but the "Risk is our business" speech.
Well, if I had to pick only *one* in TOS...

Captain Tracy January 16 2012 05:31 PM

Re: The SINGLE GREATEST MOMENT in TOS !!!
 
Quote:

SchwEnt wrote: (Post 5610523)
Maybe obvious, but the "Risk is our business" speech.
Well, if I had to pick only *one* in TOS...

Yes, one will do it.

But can you state WHY the scene works for your personally?

jayrath January 16 2012 06:42 PM

Re: The SINGLE GREATEST MOMENT in TOS !!!
 
Sorry, nope, not at all. The best moment for me, since I first saw it on a hazy black and white TV in the early 70s?

There were no special effects to it -- no explosions. No alien mysticism or anything. It was after Kirk had ruined Balok's spacecraft, and yet decided to go back: a chance to "demonstrate what our high-sounding words mean."

To not only spare your enemy, but aid him? That's Trek at its finest.

RAMA January 16 2012 08:31 PM

Re: The SINGLE GREATEST MOMENT in TOS !!!
 
There are many...I enjoy two that come to mind immediately...when Kirk looks up into the sky as he realizes they are totally alone due to the Guardian's time change in CoTEoF. Also when Bele looks incredulously at the non-understanding Kirk as he tries to explain why Lokai is inferior in LTBYLB.

RAMA

plynch January 16 2012 09:22 PM

Re: The SINGLE GREATEST MOMENT in TOS !!!
 
When they seek to understand and communicate with the Horta instead of blasting her to kingdom come out of rage and self-defense. We rise above our animal self-preservation instinct to be truly human (and Vulcan).

foxhot January 16 2012 11:11 PM

Re: The SINGLE GREATEST MOMENT in TOS !!!
 
I chose FOREVER's ending for the ending, plus the acting, the tragedy of course, plus the message which foreshadows Spock's death in TREK II of one life for many. Morning laziness kept me from elaborating too much, but it's an obvious candidate for most classic moment for all the obvious reasons. Even edited from Harlan Ellison's original version it still had a helluva lot of power. We'll never know whether it would have been received as well had Kirk deliberately prepared to SAVE Edith as in the original script. But that's what true love does to you.

King Daniel Into Darkness January 16 2012 11:58 PM

Re: The SINGLE GREATEST MOMENT in TOS !!!
 
When Number One lowers her communicator, looks up to the heavens and yells "Disengage!"

...and the Enterprise hears:cool:


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 10:08 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.