The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Miscellaneous (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=19)
-   -   Organic or 'conventional'? (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=138628)

trekkiedane March 14 2011 06:25 PM

Organic or 'conventional'?
 
I've just asked a fellow T-BBSer for a recipe and this started us talking about organic produce and products and the reasons for choosing these.

Personally I'm not religious about it, but I do buy the organic product whenever I have the choice.

The reasons I buy organic are:
  • I believe we have a responsibility to future generations; they too should live in a bio-diverse world where they can actually drink from wells and streams without fear of poisoning themselves (or indeed: a need to clean industrial waste out of our water supply).
  • It usually tastes better than 'conventional' products.
  • when given a choice, lab-animals eat organic and who are we to argue with nature?
  • Organic products contain more of the nutritionally desirable compounds and less of the nutritionally undesirable compounds.
  • Organic produce isn't dipped in poison-wax; you don't need to peel off the outer layer and can even use the peels in your cooking without any danger to yourself!

How about you? -how organic do you live? -why?/why not?

Mr. B March 14 2011 06:37 PM

Re: Organic or 'conventional'?
 
I can't afford to shop at Whole Foods and I don't believe there is any real benefit to buying "organic" food. I do buy local produce and seafood when the opportunity presents itself, though.

TerokNor March 14 2011 06:37 PM

Re: Organic or 'conventional'?
 
I buy sometimes organic vegetables/fruit. If I had more money Id buy it only, but I cannot afford it at the moment.

Meat I dont buy at all (but if I would only bio-meat), eggs I only and always buy bio-eggs. Other eggs I could not shallow. They are more expensive too, therefore I only buy like 6 eggs a month, so I can afford only buying bio-eggs.
I cannot do that with veggies though..cause then Id have nothing to eat.

I like buying organic and biologial better, because of the responsibility for the future generations, the planet, the animals, especially also the animals who "produce" things for us to eat (they should be treated fair and I just cannot eat anything when I know the animal suffered so much that you would not wsh your worst enemy that suffering).

TerokNor

trekkiedane March 14 2011 06:42 PM

Re: Organic or 'conventional'?
 
Quote:

TerokNor wrote: (Post 4809340)
/.../ the animals who "produce" things for us to eat (they should be treated fair and I just cannot eat anything when I know the animal suffered so much that you would not wsh your worst enemy that suffering).

I can't believe I forgot to put animal welfare in my list :eek:
Apparently it's not the thing I think of when talking food http://i16.photobucket.com/albums/b4...cons/Blush.gif

Jadzia March 14 2011 06:46 PM

Re: Organic or 'conventional'?
 
I buy some organic things. All of my pulses and herbs are organically grown, and they do taste significantly better than their non-organic equivalents. But for fruits and vegetables I'm not too fussy either way. I find they don't taste much different. Some of my teas are organic; some are not, and again there's not a significant difference in flavour.

I would prefer food to be grown organically -- that's an ideal to me -- but I'm often not sufficiently motivated to choose organic options.

The ideal is driven by how I think humanity should live: in harmony with the natural world, rather than through gradual obliteration of it. I don't particularly like heavy use of pesticides and artificial fertilizers, but it seems to be a necessary evil for global food production at the present time.

maclaus March 14 2011 07:00 PM

Re: Organic or 'conventional'?
 
I buy organic whenever I can. The only meat I buy is free range (which is usually, but not always, organic), so because of the cost we only eat meat once or twice a week. I find organic food usually tastes better, especially when I buy stuff from the weekly farmer's market. My husband is a keen gardener and the only chemical he uses in the garden is slug and snail pellets. Last year the little buggers ate almost all our lettuce and tomatoes, so we had no choice but to wage chemical warfare as none of the environmentally friendly methods worked.

Ru ru, chu March 14 2011 07:03 PM

Re: Organic or 'conventional'?
 
I view 'organic' as nothing more than a marketing scheme. The propaganda of the day is that anything "natural" is automatically good, and anything artificial is evil; I refuse to be suckered in by that.

cultcross March 14 2011 07:03 PM

Re: Organic or 'conventional'?
 
As there is no evidence that organic farming is better for the environment, and a mounting suggestion that it may in fact be a worse contributor to global warming than conventional agriculture, I have no particular inclination to buy organic. I am far more concerned by things like food miles than I am by organic/non-organic. Whenever possible (i.e. produce that can be grown/made in the south west of England), I will spend a bit more or go out of my way to buy local.

Given the current financial climate though, it is likely that I may soon no longer be able to afford to do so.

maclaus March 14 2011 07:07 PM

Re: Organic or 'conventional'?
 
^You have a good point regarding food miles, cultcross. The farmers' market I frequent sells only local produce, so walk away poorer but feeling very smug. ;) I agree that it's better to buy conventional local apples than organic apples from the other side of the world.

Ru ru, chu March 14 2011 07:14 PM

Re: Organic or 'conventional'?
 
I have no problem buying local - I just go to the store I work at. :)

trekkiedane March 14 2011 07:23 PM

Re: Organic or 'conventional'?
 
Quote:

Mr. Laser Beam wrote: (Post 4809410)
I view 'organic' as nothing more than a marketing scheme. The propaganda of the day is that anything "natural" is automatically good, and anything artificial is evil; I refuse to be suckered in by that.

While I did ask for opinions in my OP I had rather hoped for informed ones.
Quote:

cultcross wrote: (Post 4809412)
As there is no evidence that organic farming is better for the environment, and a mounting suggestion that it may in fact be a worse contributor to global warming than conventional agriculture, I have no particular inclination to buy organic.

Oh, but there are! (start reading here.)
Quote:

I am far more concerned by things like food miles than I am by organic/non-organic. Whenever possible (i.e. produce that can be grown/made in the south west of England), I will spend a bit more or go out of my way to buy local.
Just this Saturday I went to the local 'farmer's market' where I had the choice of locally grown tomatoes (it's winter here, darnit!) or organic ones from Spain... which ones would you buy -those that are grown conventionally in heated green-houses or those that come from thousands of kilometers away?

Ru ru, chu March 14 2011 07:28 PM

Re: Organic or 'conventional'?
 
Quote:

trekkiedane wrote: (Post 4809471)
Quote:

Mr. Laser Beam wrote: (Post 4809410)
I view 'organic' as nothing more than a marketing scheme. The propaganda of the day is that anything "natural" is automatically good, and anything artificial is evil; I refuse to be suckered in by that.

While I did ask for opinions in my OP I had rather hoped for informed ones.

I do consider that informed. I didn't mean to imply I would never buy organic, just that I wouldn't *always* buy it, out of some misbegotten notion that everything organic is always better.

trekkiedane March 14 2011 07:34 PM

Re: Organic or 'conventional'?
 
Quote:

Mr. Laser Beam wrote: (Post 4809492)
Quote:

trekkiedane wrote: (Post 4809471)
Quote:

Mr. Laser Beam wrote: (Post 4809410)
I view 'organic' as nothing more than a marketing scheme. The propaganda of the day is that anything "natural" is automatically good, and anything artificial is evil; I refuse to be suckered in by that.

While I did ask for opinions in my OP I had rather hoped for informed ones.

I do consider that informed. I didn't mean to imply I would never buy organic, just that I wouldn't *always* buy it, out of some misbegotten notion that everything organic is always better.

"I view 'organic' as nothing more than a marketing scheme." Doesn't come across as a very informed opinion though. Sounds more like something my dad would have said twenty years ago just because it was 'newfangled'.

I do however agree totally about not everything artificial being bad -or even 'evil'.

Sephiroth March 14 2011 08:08 PM

Re: Organic or 'conventional'?
 
you guys actualy BUY meat? it's called hunting, people

as for organic produce, make it affordable and more available and I'd buy more

cultcross March 14 2011 08:29 PM

Re: Organic or 'conventional'?
 
Quote:

trekkiedane wrote: (Post 4809471)
Just this Saturday I went to the local 'farmer's market' where I had the choice of locally grown tomatoes (it's winter here, darnit!) or organic ones from Spain... which ones would you buy -those that are grown conventionally in heated green-houses or those that come from thousands of kilometers away?

Well here pretty much all tomatoes are grown in greenhouses because we don't really have the climate for it, but that's by the by. In general, I would prefer something grown locally, even under artificial conditions, to something shipped in from thousands of kilometres away. The carbon cost of packaging, transport at both ends, the main journey, preserving the food during the trip, resulting increased waste etc. is enormous, and I'd have a hard time believing that running a greenhouse is worse than repeating that process over and over again to replenish stocks.

Obviously, this can't always be followed. However hard you try, there are some things the West Country will just not support. But, for example, in Sainsbury's I am faced with a choice of mushrooms from down the road in Somerset or mushrooms from Spain. You'll be pleased to know the Somerset ones are even organic :lol:


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:48 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.