The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Fan Art (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=21)
-   -   U.S.S. Discovery from Star Trek: Borderlands (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=132831)

Gorgon November 28 2010 08:17 AM

U.S.S. Discovery from Star Trek: Borderlands
 
https://sites.google.com/site/border.../Discovery.jpg

This is an image design by Roman Gitlarz. It is the introductory image to the U.S.S. Discovery Pbem-RPG website, which is found here: https://sites.google.com/site/borderlandsdiscovery/

Gorgon November 28 2010 08:18 AM

Re: U.S.S. Discovery from Star Trek: Borderlands
 
I happen to LOVE the 3D effect that Roman managed to pull off on this one. It totally rocks!

mickmike November 28 2010 08:51 AM

Re: U.S.S. Discovery from Star Trek: Borderlands
 
That is such an awesome ship. I want one.

Nightfall to-Ennien November 28 2010 09:14 AM

Re: U.S.S. Discovery from Star Trek: Borderlands
 
Nicely done, but isn't this Mark Kingsnorth's Insignia class design?

Deks November 28 2010 09:42 AM

Re: U.S.S. Discovery from Star Trek: Borderlands
 
Quote:

Nightfall to-Ennien wrote: (Post 4558156)
Nicely done, but isn't this Mark Kingsnorth's Insignia class design?

It IS.
Mark first posted it to my knowledge on Scifi-meshes website (the one that I frequented since it's creation).
If someone else is taking the credit for this design, they are trying to rip it off.
Mark would likely not appreciate someone else stealing his work.

Dac November 28 2010 12:13 PM

Re: U.S.S. Discovery from Star Trek: Borderlands
 
Yup, thats the insignia class alright. Mesh thieves deserve special hell.

Gorgon November 28 2010 02:43 PM

Re: U.S.S. Discovery from Star Trek: Borderlands
 
You are right that it is Mark Kingsworth's design. And it is an excellent one at that. I never said that the ship was Roman's design, only that it was his IMAGE design. Perhaps that was a poor word choice on my part.

We attempt to get permission for the use of other people's art in our fan-fiction sim. As I recall, Mark Kingsworth was contacted personally about the use of this craft.

Most Trek fan artists have no issue with re-use of their material. In fact, they usually encourage it. I would! To use their material indicates the highest level of appreciation for the work that they invested in the project.

sojourner November 28 2010 07:52 PM

Re: U.S.S. Discovery from Star Trek: Borderlands
 
^But you should still credit the artist.

Gorgon November 28 2010 09:15 PM

Re: U.S.S. Discovery from Star Trek: Borderlands
 
My apologies. I'll do better in the future. Thanks for the input.

RedShirt November 28 2010 10:08 PM

Re: U.S.S. Discovery from Star Trek: Borderlands
 
Sure looks an awful lot like one of the "early concepts for a Nova class starship" from page 178 of the TNG Tech Manual... just without the extra wings protruding from the now Sovereign-style warp engine nacelles.

BolianAuthor November 29 2010 03:30 AM

Re: U.S.S. Discovery from Star Trek: Borderlands
 
Quote:

Gorgon wrote: (Post 4558367)
You are right that it is Mark Kingsworth's design. And it is an excellent one at that. I never said that the ship was Roman's design, only that it was his IMAGE design. Perhaps that was a poor word choice on my part.

We attempt to get permission for the use of other people's art in our fan-fiction sim. As I recall, Mark Kingsworth was contacted personally about the use of this craft.

Most Trek fan artists have no issue with re-use of their material. In fact, they usually encourage it. I would! To use their material indicates the highest level of appreciation for the work that they invested in the project.

It's blatantly obvious your initial post was nothing more than a blatant advertisement for your RPG group, and one that was an epic fail at that, since you did not credit the original artist of the ship design.

Also, most artists DO take issue with re-use of their material... they spend lots of time on it, and don't need to see it ripped off, and mutilated into other purposes, without credit. This is why many of the REALLY skilled modelers on Sci Fi Meshes and other sites don't release their models most of the time.

And you only said you attempt to give credit to the artists AFTER you were caught with someone else's image... a very transparent move on your part. It means you're just sorry you got called out. You should have started out by saying "I don't know who the original artist is, but if someone can tell us, we will credit them".

Gorgon November 29 2010 06:45 AM

Re: U.S.S. Discovery from Star Trek: Borderlands
 
I attempted to post a note that had a rather harsh tone. Thankfully, it didn't take.

I'm going to leave it at this, and hope that you will too. I apologize for offending some peoples sense of propriety. I'll make sure that I leave nothing to chance if I post a new image.

I did know who the image was from, I even said so in my last response in this thread. I meant no disrespect to anyone, especially Mark Kingsworth. He has been nothing but good to us.

If there is an original artist to credit on a recreated photo, then I will credit the original artist as well as the later contributor.

If I must ENDURE more "correction" for the error of my ways, I'm prepared.

Have a good day.

Albertese November 30 2010 03:00 AM

Re: U.S.S. Discovery from Star Trek: Borderlands
 
As I understand it, the protocol is as follows:

1) If it's your own work, you don't really need to say so. It's implied by virtue of not being specified.

2) It it's someone's image, give credit as far as you know credit is due. If you don't know who to credit, say so up front and odds are someone will point you the right way. If not, at least you aren't accidently claiming it as yours by not specifying it isn't.

3) If it's your own render of someone else's mesh, say so and credit the mesh. Even if it's a mesh that you have modified even in just some minor cosmetic way.

If you're cribbing stuff taken from screen caps of the show, that's cool, I think we'll all understand where that came from, but specifying that it did come from the show certainly wouldn't dig you any deeper.

I hope this clears up any misunderstanding for the future! I can see how it could be easily overlooked if you're new at this game. :)

--Alex

Gorgon November 30 2010 06:31 AM

Re: U.S.S. Discovery from Star Trek: Borderlands
 
Thank you, Alex.

I just wanted to show a picture that I liked. I didn't realize what I was getting myself into. Now, I do.

Deks November 30 2010 09:18 AM

Re: U.S.S. Discovery from Star Trek: Borderlands
 
There is nothing wrong in showing a picture that you liked.
However, credits are necessary on an image if it features material that you have not made.

You can easily edit the image in Photoshop and say:
Insignia class ship by Mark Kingsworth,
Image by 'Gorgon'

Fairly simple to do and takes only a few mins.

Generally speaking, if you post images that contain material only you made, then credits are not needed, however, it IS encouraged in order to avoid others stealing your work.

I had several people over the years ask me if they can use my images in various projects.
I told them: 'Sure, so long as the said images still contain the credits I originally put on them'.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 08:43 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.