The Trek BBS

The Trek BBS (http://www.trekbbs.com/index.php)
-   Science and Technology (http://www.trekbbs.com/forumdisplay.php?f=36)
-   -   HP's competition for the iPad! (http://www.trekbbs.com/showthread.php?t=118342)

Brent April 6 2010 01:06 AM

HP's competition for the iPad!
 
http://h20435.www2.hp.com/t5/Voodoo-...nce/ba-p/54735

Multitasking. Flash. USB ports and SD slots. A Camera.

This is appealing.

Data Holmes April 6 2010 01:30 AM

Re: HP's competition for the iPad!
 
That's just a mock up at this point...

J. Allen April 6 2010 01:52 AM

Re: HP's competition for the iPad!
 
Quote:

Data Holmes wrote: (Post 3974846)
That's just a mock up at this point...

The technology is already there, particularly if you've seen the latest HP desktop touch. Give it a few months at max, and it will be on store shelves, and HP will sell it for significantly less than the iPad, and it will be far superior in terms of flexibility.

Robert Maxwell April 6 2010 01:59 AM

Re: HP's competition for the iPad!
 
What is old is new again. :lol: I guess I'll feel vindicated if the iPad actually makes slate computing less of a joke than it's always been.

Mr. B April 6 2010 02:03 AM

Re: HP's competition for the iPad!
 
It's like an iPad... that you can plug a thumb drive in to... Awesome!

Data Holmes April 6 2010 02:09 AM

Re: HP's competition for the iPad!
 
Quote:

Axiom wrote: (Post 3974944)
Quote:

Data Holmes wrote: (Post 3974846)
That's just a mock up at this point...

The technology is already there, particularly if you've seen the latest HP desktop touch. Give it a few months at max, and it will be on store shelves, and HP will sell it for significantly less than the iPad, and it will be far superior in terms of flexibility.

By that point in time, iP os 4.X will be out which is supposed to offer multitasking, Flash isn't as important an issue as apple is winning that war with many sites going html5 because of the iPad, I don't see any functional benefit to having USB ports on a PADD type device, as it's primary method of data transfer will be wireless via bluetooth or wifi. So the only thing this thing will really have as a built in over the iPad is the SD card reader capability.

By the way, if USB or SD card ability is that big a deal, the Apple iPad Camera kit http://store.apple.com/us/product/MC531ZM/A gives you both abilities for $29.

Mr. B April 6 2010 02:22 AM

Re: HP's competition for the iPad!
 
Quote:

Data Holmes wrote: (Post 3974984)
By the way, if USB or SD card ability is that big a deal, the Apple iPad Camera kit http://store.apple.com/us/product/MC531ZM/A gives you both abilities for $29.

Come on... you know damn well how incredibly pathetic it is to exclude a USB port or card reader from a device like this. It's just plain sad... and an artificial limitation because Apple has a stupid tiered pricing scheme for internal memory. An SDXC slot of the iPad would destroy their ridiculous pricing for 16gb/32gb/etc models.

A USB port on a tablet would make it easy for people to interact with actual FILES on the device and make it a useful tool for photographers in the field... or just about anyone else that might want to transfer music, video, documents, whatever. If I want to move something from a computer it's pretty darn easy to drag and drop rather than establish a BT connection.

Alidar Jarok April 6 2010 02:34 AM

Re: HP's competition for the iPad!
 
Yeah, flash drives offer convenience and ability to transfer things to everyone regardless of technology or skill level. Not having one almost seems like an oversight.

That being said, I'm pissed off at HP right now, so I probably won't be getting their competition.

Flavius April 6 2010 02:49 AM

Re: HP's competition for the iPad!
 
All the better if the iPad is getting some serious competition.

Data Holmes April 6 2010 03:02 AM

Re: HP's competition for the iPad!
 
Quote:

Mr. B wrote: (Post 3975042)
Quote:

Data Holmes wrote: (Post 3974984)
By the way, if USB or SD card ability is that big a deal, the Apple iPad Camera kit http://store.apple.com/us/product/MC531ZM/A gives you both abilities for $29.

Come on... you know damn well how incredibly pathetic it is to exclude a USB port or card reader from a device like this. It's just plain sad... and an artificial limitation because Apple has a stupid tiered pricing scheme for internal memory. An SDXC slot of the iPad would destroy their ridiculous pricing for 16gb/32gb/etc models.

A USB port on a tablet would make it easy for people to interact with actual FILES on the device and make it a useful tool for photographers in the field... or just about anyone else that might want to transfer music, video, documents, whatever. If I want to move something from a computer it's pretty darn easy to drag and drop rather than establish a BT connection.

You fail to see the future, my friend. Devices such as this are not storage devices... Much like the ahead of it's time concept from TNG, the iPad is a Personal Access Display Device.

What does this mean, that you don't need super amounts of storage built in. Why, because the vast majority will all be stored, and protected, off device. In the home, it will access your media server, a computer with 4 or 5 tb of storage. Music, pics, movies, tv, all streamed over wireless to your device. Not home, you have the "cloud" to access such things, streaming iTunes is mere months away at this point, Hulu, Netflix, Youtube, ect... everything media content wise is accessible over the "web". Apple is starting to take this further with MobileMe, which adds even more "networked" abilities to the device.

The key with PADD like devices right now, is to resist the urge to think of them as "tablet PC's" or "netbook replacements" because these things are not computers and shouldn't be thought of as such. It's an access point, a Window if you will, to content, to the internet, ect.

On board storage is really, if you look at it in these terms, for downloaded apps, and limited downloaded content for use "off network".


Apple really has it's head in trek as far as this is going.

iPhone and iPod Touch = Communicator/tricorder
iPad = PADD's

Hell, the entire apple family of products could be equated to the various levels of trek computers, Even iPhone OS has been equated as a real world LCARS, which is fitting really as it stood for Library Computer Access/Retrieval System A UI designed for simplicity to access information from a central library computer storage database...

Why does that sound familiar again? Because that is exactly what apple's CE devices do.

Look at trek, and you will see where apple is headed.

Jetfire April 6 2010 03:12 AM

Re: HP's competition for the iPad!
 
I would rather have an HP Slate, than and iPad.

TheGodBen April 6 2010 03:23 AM

Re: HP's competition for the iPad!
 
Quote:

Data Holmes wrote: (Post 3974984)
Flash isn't as important an issue as apple is winning that war with many sites going html5 because of the iPad

Apple will never win the HTML5 v flash war. No company will. As it stands HTML5 video will not come with any DRM restrictions (something flash does have), so if you are watching a video on YouTube all you need to do is right-click and download it. That's fine for most of the user-made videos on the site, but official videos from media providers will not allow a system where their content can be downloaded by even the dumbest of internet users. For this reason YouTube's HTML5 beta does not play videos with ads, for that it goes back to flash. Official music videos will probably have the same limitation if they don't have it already. A website like Hulu will probably never make the move to HTML5 video.

Flash isn't going anywhere any time soon, and Apple's probably not going to add flash to the iPad/iPhone any time soon.

Brent April 6 2010 03:26 AM

Re: HP's competition for the iPad!
 
Quote:

Flavius wrote: (Post 3975105)
All the better if the iPad is getting some serious competition.

Agreed, competition drives down prices, and drives up innovation.


And I agree about the iPad = PADD analogy above. Though, certainly, greater storage capacity is welcomed, and with that competition again helps. No specs yet on the HP Slate, we'll see what they opt to do there.

Lindley April 6 2010 03:31 AM

Re: HP's competition for the iPad!
 
Quote:

Mr. B wrote: (Post 3975042)
Come on... you know damn well how incredibly pathetic it is to exclude a USB port or card reader from a device like this.

Perhaps. It may be too early to tell, really. Remember when everyone said the same thing about Apple's decision not to include a floppy drive on the iMac?

Flavius April 6 2010 03:46 AM

Re: HP's competition for the iPad!
 
Apple has a vision, you have got to give them that - they are trying to turn those devices into appliances and at the same time care about design.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 07:13 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2015, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
FireFox 2+ or Internet Explorer 7+ highly recommended.