Poll Do you like SNW and Discovery? (Poll)

Absolutely love Christine/Spock. It's the core of the show.

 

maybe I will find out one day

 

Actually no. Because there are so many things that different between SNW and Discovery season 2 in Aesthetic department. Specially the looks of Klingon. The Enterprise uniform also different, although they have the same design. And the Enterprise Interior, where in Discovery they looks so red.

For me, it feel that they come from 2 different dimension. Although both of them share the same events. But even with that, there are a lot of tiny difference between the two of them.

 

SNW is nothing like Discovery.

 

So...TOS to TMP to TWOK.

 

The looks of the Klingons also changed from DIS S1 to Dis S2 as well. And there’s nothing preventing the DIS Klingons and SNW Klingons from sharing the same screen at once. It would be better that way, seeing as they are an empire and empires are diverse.

Which were just Disco uniforms spraypainted to resemble TOS. Even though they should have look more like the uniforms specifically from The Cage/WNMAGB, but that’s a different thing.

The Enterprise was also really dark. The red was to liven the ship up.

 

They did, briefly. It was the second season SNW episode with the Klingons, the "new" Klingons are in the foreground, but some background Klingons are definitely in the DSC prosthetics.

 

The sides of Dak'Rah's bald head felt pretty DSC-like. More Season 2 since no elongated head.

And it was the same in DSC Season 2. Any Klingon with a full head of hair used the new makeup, but there were still some bald or mostly bald Klingons still using the Season 1 makeup.

 

They feel similar because of the newer effects and similar set quality, but I feel they're completely different tonally. SNW I enjoy more because of the ensemble cast and semi-episodic structure, and DSC I dislike (generally) because of it's serialization.

 

SNW: Yes!
DSC: Dear god, NO.

 

I enjoy SNW very much- I am not a subscriber but purchased the discs when they were released. I saw some clips on line and was very impressed.

I respect STD's visuals and SFX, but I do not care much for the stories and characters. I have also seen a lot of clips, much more than SNW, and nothing I saw made me want to watch a full episode.

 

I like both, but SNW much more than DSC.